April 6, 2011

Answer Me This!


A sustainable organization is able to identify, strengthen and leverage social aspects where shared value between the organization and society exists. Business needs a healthy society, and society needs healthy business.

Three Questions:

1. How does your organization identify the communities your organization has an impact on and / or is dependent?

2. How does your organization determine areas for organizational involvement and / or interest?

3. How does your organization actively support and strengthen your key communities?


Read more: "How Good Is Your Vision? Can Your Competitors See Opportunities You Can't?"

January 17, 2011


“The prevailing approaches to CSR are so disconnected from business as to obscure many of the greatest opportunities for companies to benefit society” says Porter, a globally renowned business strategist.

The role of corporate social responsibility (CSR) in business has obtained some traction in recent years (a lot of traction in fact!), but still in most cases it asserts itself through only a list of charitable deeds and philanthropic pittances placed in a dazzling report. For some companies, corporate social responsibility is a cost and a constraint, culminating in a cunning, cosmetic PR campaign. But it doesn’t have to be so. – To ensure the longevity of your enterprise, it can’t be so! Being socially responsible should give your organization a competitive advantage and it should lead to opportunity and innovation.

A CSR strategy starts with a simple (and obvious) belief; business needs a healthy society, and society needs healthy business. This belief is the foundational element of the shared value concept that Michael Porter and Mark Kramer espouse. “The mutual dependence of corporations and society implies that both business decisions and social policies must follow the principles of shared value. That is, choices must benefit both sides.” (Porter et al., 2006) These Lords of Strategy warn that if an organization or society pursue selfish interests that only benefit one side, they’re heading down a dangerous path. “A temporary gain to one will undermine the long-term prosperity of both.” (Porter et al., 2006) Any business that operates at the expense of society will experience only fleeting success; it’s just not sustainable.

So how do you find opportunities for shared value? First, begin with a sustainability strategy rooted in the notion of social integration. Start by considering all the points of intersection between the organization and society, both positive and negative. Look at your value chain. Porter et al. (2006) suggest you look ‘inside out’; map the social impact of the activities your company engages in during the course of business. Then look ‘outside in’ and consider all the social dimensions that can affect the company’s competitiveness.

The ‘inside out’ and ‘outside in’ discovery will detect those areas with the greatest strategic value; the areas that impact the companies competitiveness and for which organizational resources and capability is present to leverage. “When a well-run business applies its vast resources, expertise, and management talent to problems that it understands and in which it has a stake, it can have a greater impact on social good than any other institution or philanthropic organization.” (Porter et al., 2006) Likewise, when a business discovers opportunities for shared value with society, it enhances its pursuit of innovation, increases productivity in its value chain and overcomes social constraints to competitiveness.

Reference: Porter, Michael, and Kramer, Mark. 2006. Strategy and Society – The Link Between Competitive Advantage and Corporate Social Responsibility. Harvard Business Review. December Edition, Pg. 78-92.

December 26, 2010


The term Greenwashing is used to describe companies that use false or misleading environmental claims in an attempt to paint themselves a certain shade of green.

Terrachoice, an environmental marketing agency, has compiled the 7 Sins of Greenwashing to assist in bringing awareness to this tactic. Take heed of the sins. An allegation of Greenwashing can result in great harm to your company’s reputation.

The sins are:


Sin of the Hidden Trade-Off

Suggesting a product is green based on a narrow set of attributes and excluding other important issues


Sin of No Proof

Making a claim that cannot be substantiated


Sin of Vagueness

A poorly defined or broad claim that doesn’t clearly have real meaning to the consumer


Sin of Irrelevance

The claim may be truthful but is unimportant or meaningless (i.e. indicating a product is “CFC Free”, where the use of CFCs are illegal)


Sin of Lesser of Two Evils

The claim may be truthful but distracts the consumer from the greater environmental issue within the product category


Sin of Fibbing

Making false environmental claims


Sin of Worshipping False Labels

Suggesting a third party endorsement where no such endorsement exists

Source: Terrachoice. 2010. “The Sins of Greenwashing; A Report on Environmental Claims Made in the North American Consumer Market”. Pg.10


December 14, 2010


Did you read the Canadian Securities Association staff notice 51-333 yet? What? You didn’t? – I know…This is likely not something that has made it to your nightstand. But in spite of it being a relatively laborious read, the notice does provide some clarity on environmental reporting requirements in Canada. Specifically, the notice attempts to clarify disclosure requirements related to the impact of environmental matters on revenues, expenditures, cash flows, liquidity and general performance under National Instrument 51-102 Continuous Disclosure Obligations.

Disclosure requirements under National Instrument 51-102 are typically the basis for environmental sustainability reporting. These requirements are related to:

Environmental risks – Those risks related to litigation, and physical, regulatory, reputational and business model risks;

Trends and uncertainties – Commitments, events, risks and uncertainties that are believed to impact future performance;

Environmental liabilities – Liabilities including compliance obligations, site remediation obligations, fines related to statutory or regulatory non-compliance, obligations to compensate private parties for personal injury, property damage and economic loss, payment for punitive damages, and natural resource damages;

Asset retirement obligations – The legal requirements related to retirement of an asset, which may include remediation, reclamation and disposal of hazardous waste;

Financial and operational effects of environmental protection requirements – The effects of protection requirements on capital expenditures, earnings and competitive position;

Environmental policies fundamental to operations – The disclosure of policies fundamental to the operation of the business including sustainable development, community relation, disposal of toxic / hazardous materials, prevention of spills, recycling, water conservation, and reduction of greenhouse gas emissions;

Board mandate and committees – Information related to how the board manages risk, and,

Forward looking information – Possible events, conditions or results of operations that are based on assumptions about future economic conditions and courses of action (e.g. goals and targets related to environmental matters).

The notice also re-iterates some examples of how environmental matters could impact, positively or negatively, the financial condition of your business. Obviously, you should take note of these:

  • Changes in consumer preference or demand for goods and services due to environmental matters or trends;
  • Changes in supply chain requirements related to environmental matters;
  • New rules requiring design changes to products;
  • Delayed or denied regulatory approvals;
  • The availability and price of emissions credits or offsets;
  • The need to retrofit existing facilities to address physical, health and safety, or regulatory constraints;
  • Research and development activities related to more environmentally efficient operations and processes;
  • Increased or new insurance coverage or premiums;
  • Penalties for failure to meet government-mandated reduction targets;
  • Repairing or rebuilding facilities impacted by adverse weather events;
  • Investments in productive capacity that embody new “green” or more energy-efficient technologies;

For more details, take a look at CSA Staff Notice 51-333 Environmental Reporting Guidance (October 27, 2010).


December 12, 2010


Take a moment to explore the space between book value and market capitalization and you’ll find it’s laden with intangible assets. The value of an enterprise was once the sum of its physical parts, but not anymore. Intangibles assets, such as brand equity, reputation, recognition, stakeholder relationships, knowledge, patents, and human capital, play a growing importance in the valuation of a business. How important? Well, have a look at these numbers…the majority of which were calculated based upon an analysis of S&P 500 companies.
 
  Composition of Company Value*
Year
Intangible (%)
Tangible (%)
1982
38
62
1992
62
38
1998**
71
29
2000
85
15







This shift in the source of company value has required a new view of how an organization captures, creates and delivers value and a re-prioritization of business risks and opportunities. 

*   Ulrich, Dave and Smallwood, Norm. 2003. Why the Bottom Line Isn't! John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Pg.11.
** Willard, Bob. 2007. The Business Case for Sustainability. SustainabiliTV.

December 8, 2010


The concept eludes many, and its vastness and vagueness can be daunting to business. But, incise the idea, shed the semantics and you’ll discover what sustainability is; what it means to your organization, and what’s meaningful to your business.

Depending on the attributes of an organization, sustainability can and will mean different things. But in general, sustainability is simply defined as success in perpetuity; it’s the business’s capacity to endure. Sustainability is comprehensive - there are social, environmental, and economic dimensions - thriving only in one dimension is not sustainable. If you’re meeting your environmental goals, but the venture isn't profitable, your business is not sustainable.

Here are some (just a few) of the attributes that define a sustainable organization:

The business is creating, delivering and capturing value in a sustainable way;

Assets (tangible and intangible) are sustainably managed, optimized and revitalized when required;

The business has a mechanism to foster and surface innovation and good ideas no matter where in the organization they’re generated;

Environmental and social aspects are considered on the basis of what the business will take ownership of, action on, or an interest in, and what is immaterial;

Wealth and value is created for all stakeholders (internal and external);

Business functions are aligned with a sound dynamic strategy to endure in perpetuity;

Risks to the enterprise are identified and understood. Risk responses are planned;

The business has a successful mechanism to continually adapt and manage change; and,

The organization capitalizes on opportunities realized through changes in society, government, technology and natural and human resources.